Video Game Shopping for Xbox 360?

I have a $25 dollar giftcard to Target (I can use cash, but I kind of want to just use the giftcard), but I want a new Video Game for XBOX 360, I already have the hot new titles - MW3 - Halo CEA - BF3 - Skyrim - Saints Row 3, but I would like another game, I do have some ideas on the game I might buy here:

- Fallout: New Vegas

- Batman Arkham Asylum

- Gears of War 1 or 2

- Mass Effect 2

- Create

- Medal of Honor

- Bio Shock 2

- Dante鈥檚 Inferno

- Dragon Age

- Homefront



I have never played any of these games so what game should I get or should I get a different game? Please Help! Leave a few suggestions and rank them if you can/want to.

The only games I might spend extra money for are

- Assassins Creed Brotherhood

- Lord of the Rings: War In the North



What game should I get???????Video Game Shopping for Xbox 360?
Most games cost way over $25. I would get either batman (it was the highest rated game this year) or halo reach.